S3 101. Embracing Experimentation: The Creator's Path to Success with Top 0.5% Podcaster Jay Clouse
The creator economy is on the rise—projected to skyrocket to an eye-popping $450 billion by 2026. As a podcaster and digital creator, I know firsthand how tempting it is to focus only on monetization: merch, memberships, sponsorships. But in this ever-evolving space, a more critical question lingers—how do we make intentional, focused decisions that not only increase revenue but build sustainable, long-term growth?
This question is at the core of this season, where I’m diving into strategies that go beyond surface-level advice. In previous episodes, I spoke to experts like Liz Mosley about monetizing through branded merch and Justin Moore on mastering sponsorships. But this time, I wanted to go deeper—to tap into the mindset behind a successful ‘creator-scientist’. That’s why I brought on someone I admire immensely for both his transparency and his results: Jay Clouse.
Chapters:
00:02:30 – What it truly means to be a creator vs being an artist.
00:04:30 – The stages of the creator journey and why mapping the audience’s emotional arc matters.
00:07:00 – Embracing imperfect content and showing the messy middle.
00:08:30 – Sharing vulnerabilities while maintaining audience trust.
00:11:30 – Redefining success and the question of what "enough" looks like.
00:14:30 – Why YouTube was a long game and when it finally became worthwhile.
00:16:30 – How publishing less but with higher quality led to rapid YouTube growth.
00:25:30 –"Experimentality" as a mindset for growth through experimentation.
00:26:30 – How small, consistent improvements lead to big creator success.
Jay is the host of Creator Science and a trusted voice in the creator economy. His work empowers digital creators to think differently, work smarter, and become trusted voices in their industry. During our conversation—recorded amidst the clamor of real-life home construction—I was reminded that high-level thinking doesn’t need a flawless backdrop. In fact, embracing the messy middle might be one of the most powerful things a creator can do.
Defining what a creator is
Jay and I started off by exploring the identity of a creator. He defines a creator as someone who makes digital content with their audience in mind—not just for self-expression, but for impact, enjoyment, and utility. Whether you’re working in video, writing, or podcasting, Jay argues that the through-line is intentionality: your work should speak to someone and serve a purpose beyond just "putting something out there."
One of the most valuable parts of our chat was Jay’s breakdown of the customer journey. He shared how he builds content with specific audience milestones in mind—from discovery to scaling—and uses emotional mapping to ensure his content resonates when his audience needs it most. This strategic empathy helps creators guide their communities through challenging moments and toward meaningful progress.
Strategic transparency with context and data
We also explored a topic so many creators shy away from: vulnerability. Jay has built a reputation for transparency—openly sharing his wins and losses. He admits that publishing raw or uncertain content still makes him nervous, but doing so has deepened audience trust. That kind of honesty, he says, is what separates fleeting attention from loyal engagement. It’s not about being perfect—it’s about being useful, real, and consistent.
Then, of course, we talked platforms—especially YouTube. Jay didn’t sugarcoat it. Success there took him 13 months of intense focus and over $50K in investment. What made the difference? Understanding YouTube’s preference for quality over quantity, learning what makes a thumbnail click-worthy, and letting go of the need to post weekly just to stay “in the game.” If you’ve been feeling pressure to jump onto every new content trend, his story is a refreshing reminder to invest in what works for you.
Throughout the episode, Jay shared how social media burnout made him rethink how he engages with his audience. He’s moved away from hyper-optimized, viral-chasing posts and embraced a more conversational, authentic approach. Growth might be slower, but it’s steadier—and for him, it feels more aligned. As creators, we often forget we have the power to redefine success on our own terms.
The mindset of experimentation
By the end of our conversation, one idea really stuck with me: “experi-mentality.” This is Jay’s term for the mindset that fuels growth in the creator world. It’s not about overnight virality or finding one perfect formula. It’s about running thoughtful experiments, learning from every result—good or bad—and making tiny, consistent changes that lead to something big over time. It’s not luck. It’s iteration.
So, if you’ve been feeling overwhelmed, stuck, or unsure about your next step as a creator, this episode is your permission slip to keep going—but with more intention and curiosity. Let this be your reminder: growth is rarely linear, and clarity comes through action.
Related content you should play next:
RESOURCES MENTIONED IN THE EPISODE:
Connect to Jay Clouse and subscribe to his Creator Science Podcast: http://creatorscience.com
Learn about Becky Pearson’s framework: https://www.beckypierson.com
→Feeling stuck about your podcast’s growth? Do you have no idea where to start and want to partner up with a pro? Book a free discovery call or learn about what we do: https://thepodcastspace.com/grow-roi
💸 Affiliate links*:
Captivate.fm (Podcast Hosting platform)- https://bit.ly/3ZFbvjQ
Riverside.fm (Record high-quality interviews)- https://bit.ly/46C7A9E
Kit (Newsletter Provider) - https://partners.convertkit.com/thepodcastspace
Custom Neon (Neon sign) - 10% OFF https://bit.ly/48G5Aiq use code THEPODCASTSPACE10
*Understand that by clicking the links above, The Podcast Space may collect a small percentage of the total value. We only recommend products and services we believe in.
ABOUT THE HOST
Hi, I’m Ana Xavier, a multilingual award-winning podcast marketing and content strategist specialized in generating online visibility for women, multilingual, and minority impact-driven business owners.
Want to keep learning?
Check these episodes next…
